AN ASSESSMENT OF MASS MEDIA CAMPAIGN AGAINST FEMALE GENITAL MUTILATION (FGM) IN AGENEBODE, ETSAKO EAST LOCAL GOVERNMENT AREA
ABSTRACT
ABSTRACT
The aim of this research is to determine why media
campaigns against female genital mutilation (FGM) in Agenebode, headquarter of
Etsako East Local Government Area, are not making positive impact on her indigenes,
because the practice is very rampant in the locality. This study, however,
still relies on the premise that media campaign is an essential tool for
correcting or eliminating a social ill.
A questionnaire was therefore designed and administered in
the locality to determine the cause of the persistence of the F.G.M practice.
The major reason deduced, amongst many, is that Etsako people in this community
are resistant to change due to their strong believe in tradition.
This study therefore recommends that government authorities
and NGOs should adopt a new formula in their campaigns against FGM practice.
Secondly, media campaigns should include puritive consequences against any
known FGM perpetrators in their campaign content.
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
Cover page
Title page
Certification
Dedication
Acknowledgement
Abstract
Table of contents
CHAPTER
ONE
1.1
Background
of the study
1.2
Scope
of study
1.3
Statement
of the problem
1.4
Purpose
of the study
1.5
Objectives
of the study
1.6
Significance
of the study
1.7
Research
methodology
1.8
Limitations
of the study
1.9
Definition
of operational terms
CHAPTER
TWO
2.1
Evolution
of mass media
2.2
Post-Independence
press
2.3
Development
of Broadcasting
2.4
Component
of the mass media
2.5
Television
broadcast
2.6
Radio
2.7
Planning
mass media campaign
2.8
Communication
campaigns
2.9
The
issues on female genital mutilation
CHAPTER
THREE
3.1
Population
of the study
3.2
Sample
of the study
3.3
Research
design
3.4
Sampling
techniques
3.5
Description
for research instrument
3.6
Method
of data analysis
CHAPTER
FOUR
4.1
Data
presentation
4.2
Presentation
and analysis of demographic data
4.3
Presentation
analysis of Psychographic Data
4.4
Discussion
of findings
4.5
Summary
of findings
CHAPTER
FIVE
5.1
Summary
observation
5.2
Recommendation
5.3
Conclusion
Work cited
Appendix
CHAPTER
ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1
BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
The mass media plays an
important role in the society by entertaining, enlightening and educating
citizenry. The media usually comes in between creation and distribution reflecting
the use of the term medium to describe the means of passing mass information to
the audience. According to Steinberg (1972) the media includes
Radio,
television and wire services,
National
magazines, motion picture
(film)
and to some extents books. (B).
Mass media campaigns therefore
remain an important strategy for health promotion, social orientation and
disease preventions since 1940s. Yet, considerable debate surround the
effectiveness of those campaigns that take the form of series of television and
radio public service announcement (PSAS) with collation of print materials such
as posters, booklets, brochures, handbills, leaflets and billboard displays.
Non governmental organization
(NGOS) are often involved as intermediaries to help disseminate the message of
the campaigns. In Nigeria,
mass media campaigns have been conducted on topics covering general health
issues like immunization, birth control, cancer control, mental health, lung
disease and HIV/AIDS e.t.c.
In recent years female
circumcision here is after referred to as female Genital mutilation (FGM) is of
course one of the age long trado cultural practices that have drawn the
attention of government and non-governmental organizations in many countries of
the world. FGM recognized by many as an issue of medical, social and legal
practice has a long and complex history. At present F.G.M remains common in
many cultures in Africa and the middle East,
varying in forms and severity as a result of each group’s socio cultural norms
and belief systems.
It can have severe medical and
psychological consequences for the girl child and woman on whom it is
performed. As the World Health Organization (WHO) 2002 has stated,
Changes
in individual behaviour
World
seem to require both the
Provision
of accurate information
and the
reduction of mis information. (27).
In this regard, enormous amount
of money has been spent on campaigns intended to discourage the practice as
well as educate the populace on the inherent damage the practice has on the
female child. People receive a number of influences as a result of their
exposure to the media and differ in their receptivity to these influences.
However the essence of this study
is to among other things ascertain the level of effectiveness of the various
mass media campaigns on awareness, knowledge, attitude and the desired
behavioural change. Moreover, the study will also find out the people’s
perception towards media campaign messages in Agenebode.
1.2
SCOPE OF STUDY
The focus of this study is an
assessment of media campaigns against Female genital mutilation (FGM) in
Agenebode, the headquarter of Etsako East local Government Area of Edo State.
The choice of Agenebode is motivated by the fact that FGM practice in Agenebode
is still very rampant inspite of several media campaigns against the practice
which are broadcast on state, and federal governments owned electronic media as
well as privately owned media stations, all signals of which are received in
Agenebode. There is also the presence of the print media in Agenebode because
there are major Nigerian dailies that cannot be bought in various News paper
stands in the local government headquarter.
This study therefore believes
that the persistence of FGM practice in Agenebode is not because there are not
enough media campaigns against it but that the Etsako people in this community
are resistant to change due to their strong belief in tradition. There may be
need for government authorities and NGOs to adopt a new formula in their campaigns
against FGM practice. First of all, media campaigns should include puritive
consequences against any known FGM perpetrators in their campaign content.
Secondly, government authorities and NGOs should sponsor a lot of persistent
outdoor activities against FGM practice in schools, market places and in
churches and mosques. These should include drama sketches and open air propaganda.
Any recently known FGM practitioner should be prosecuted and sentenced in order
to deter others from the practice.
1.3
STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM
Over the century, thousands of
mass media campaigns have disseminated messages about dozens of different
health topics to the Nigerian public. Government and health associations have sought
to educate and persuade the public to adopt healthy practice or to avoid
behaviour that pose a risk to health such as female genital mutilation (FGM)
through frequent and prominent placement of paid health messages in the mass
media.
However, despite the high
resources committed to this course, there is still a prevalence of these
unhealthy practices. The effectiveness of these mass media campaigns is then
questioned. Despite the heavy flow of multimedia messages they have produced
almost no sign or evidence in knowledge gained and effective desire to change
or modify undesirable behavioural, attitudinal lifestyles. This pessimistic outlook
might be as a result of the target public high resistant to mediated messages,
apathy, attitudinal defensiveness and cognitive ineptness.
This study however, will seek
to fill this knowledge gap specifically in Agenebode, Etsako East Local
government area of Edo
State.
1.4
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY
The purpose of the study, is to
investigate the effectiveness of mass media campaign interventions in
influencing public behaviour. The essence however, is to establish direct links
between mass media campaign interventions and subsequent public awareness,
knowledge, attitude and behavioural change against FGM in Agenebode, Etsako East
local Government Area of Edo State.
1.5
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
Based on the general background
and purpose, the research focuses on the following specific objectives
i. To
find out the effectiveness of mass media campaign in generating awareness and
knowledge on the harmful effects of FGM
ii. To
find out the degree to which the various campaigns have led to change in
behaviour and attitude.
iii. To find out which mass media (Electronic or Print) has the
greatest influence on the campaign influence on the campaign against FGM in
Agenebode, Etsako East Local Government Area of Edo State.
iv. To
ascertain the perception of the people towards mass media campaign messages in
Agenebode.
1.6
SIGNIFICANCE OF THE STUDY
No doubt, mass media campaign
plays an influential role in many societies. Therefore understanding and
ascertaining their level of effectiveness in generating awareness, knowledge
and sensitization leading to desired behavioural change is imperative.
Considering the huge amount spent on mass media campaigns interventions, the
findings of this study will help government and non-government organization
(NGOs) set priorities, re-strategize and deploy resources wisely to the
specific mass media or mediums that will be effective in achieving their goals.
Moreso, the findings will also
be beneficial to advertising agencies and media firms in policy and strategies
formulation. The research hopes to contribute immensely to existing pool of
knowledge on mass media campaigns strategies and effectiveness in Nigeria. Finally,
it will serve as a useful reference to future researchers.
1.7
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
The target population of this
study will consist of students in secondary and tertiary institutions, market
men and women who have lock up shops in Agenebode local market and local
government council employees. The sample of the study shall consist of 40 men
and women who have lock up shops, 20 members of staff of Etsako East local
Government council, 40 students in secondary and tertiary institutions will
constitute the third sample group. The sample population will therefore amount
to 100.
A survey method of gathering
data will be used in the study. A sample questionnaire will be drawn and
administered. The data gathered will be analysed using simple percentage and
descriptive method.
1.8 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
Library resources and other information on this topic were
relatively old and obsolete. Time and financial constraints also greatly slowed
down the process of gathering information. Most on-line sources of information
required financial subscriptions. Time was insufficient due to pressure from
other academic activities.
The above limitations not withstanding, this researcher was
not deterred by these challenges but worked tirelessly to meet her objectives
in order to produce a reliable study.
1.9 DEFINITION OF OPERATIONAL TERMS
Mass media is a channel of communication, for example,
television, radio through which messages flow and are produced by a few for
consumption by many people. Units of communication, television, radio station,
newspapers and magazines Ogbiten B.O (2008).
CAMPAIGN
Any deliberate effort planned and directed towards
identified audience purposely to sensitize and influence (shape or reshape)
their attitude and behaviour concerning a thing (Ogbiten, 2008).
MASS
MEDIA CAMPAIGN
In this research work mass media campaign refers to a
deliberate, designed and planned means and series of information and
communication activities through the media to a large number of audiences with
a set purpose of influencing their ideas, behaviour and knowledge, e.t.c.
FEMALE
GENITAL MUTILATION
The use of this word in this study refers to cutting the
clitoris of the female organ by harming or depriving it of its natural
functions to a woman, especially by cutting or tearing off part of it (Oxford
Dictionary) in this case of this study this will mean the female genital organ
(virgina)
CHAPTER
TWO
LITERATURE
REVIEW
2.1
EVOLUTION OF MASS MEDIA
Mass media in Nigeria has
come a long way. It has its roots in colonialism and through the missionary
efforts of Rt. Reverend Henry Townsend of the church missionary society (CMS).
According to Sambe (2005:149) commenting on the evolution and nature of the
Nigerian mass media, quotes a British media scholar Peter Golding as having
said that
Nigerian
press was born of anti-colonial
Protest,
baptized in the flood of nationalist
Propaganda
and mature in party politics
Sambe (2005:149) argued that
this view succinctly drives home the point about the Nigerian media that they
preceded what come to be known as Nigeria by 1913 when Lord Lugard amalgamated
the Northern and Southern protectorates. In other words, the media and the
Nigerian newspaper existed before there came into being on entity called Nigeria. It was
on December 3, 1859 that the first Newspaper, Iwe Rohin, was set up in Abeokuta by Revered Henry
Townsend, an Anglican missionary. Iwe Irohin, Which later became bilingual,
published in Yoruba and English disappeared from the newsstands in October 1867
following the expulsion of its proprietors and subsequent destruction of its
printing press during a popular revolt. It was not until the late 1880s that
popular newspapers emerged as educated Africans were becoming disillusioned and
frustrated because of the contradictions between the professed benovelence of
Christian colonialism and its alienating, exploitative nature and because of
the racial indignities suffered by the natives. Taking advantage of the growing
literature population and the expansion in the printing industry, the Africans
founded newspapers that spear-headed a brand of nationalism that was both
cultural and political.
The newspapermen at this time
were professional and vocational journalist who took a possible role in
politics and active in social live (Omu in Sambe 2005: 150). The activities of
the pressmen at that time were identical with the intellectual and material
development of Nigeria.
Dr Azikiwe himself later joined the horde of African journalists and publishers
establishing a chain of newspapers, of which the West African pilot was the
daily Times, which had been established in 1926 by a group of expatriates, that
actually revolutionized by the state of the media in Nigeria. Daily Times was
later incorporated in the mirror group of London
and became the technical pivot of the Nigerian press. It expanded rapidly and
its effective distribution and strategy led rival newspapers to seek ways of
meeting the challenges it posed. In 1949 Obafemi Awolowo, leader of the Action
group and former journalist, founded the Nigerian Tribune (Sambe 2005:150).
The period 1950, witnessed the
establishment of radio and television, development of monthly magazines and the
entry of government into the newspaper industry, hitherto, largely a monopoly
of the Private sector and political parties. In 1960, the Eastern Nigerian Government,
led by Dr. Azikiwe converted the Weekly Eastern Nigerian Outlook into a daily
newspaper and renamed it Nigerian Outlook. The following year, the federal
Government Established the Morning post and Sunday post. In 1966 Western
Nigerian government set up by the Daily Sketch. In January 1966, barely a week
before the first military coup of January 15th, the Northern
Nigerian government floated the New Nigerian Newspaper (NNW), which absorbed
the leading vernacular newspapers Gasklya Ta Fi Kwabo published by the Gasklya
corporation, Zaria.
2.2
POST-INDEPENDENCE PRESS
Soon after the independence of Nigeria, many
regional governments realized the power of the newspapers and a disturbing
trend crept in to media practice. According to Dare in Sambe (2005:15)
Because of the failure to
distinguish between the ruling party and the government, they were for all
practical purposes, party organs financed by the public, through crude and over
Zealous
Partisanship. They transformed
opponents of the ruling party into dissents with disloyalty.
The different problems visible
in the press, at that time, were biases, partisanship, half truths and
pernicious propaganda. Shortly after the civil war and the era of oil boom,
there was proliferation of newspapers and magazines such as concord, vanguard, Daily star and the Guardian. Though there was quality
improvement in content and colours but there was the problem of
professionalism.
2.3
DEVELOPMENT OF BROADCASTING
The development of the
broadcast media is not as dramatic as the print. It started roughly 75 years
after print, precisely 1935, through the establishment of the Radio
Distribution service. This was intimated by the British colonialists to serve
as a means of communication and contact with events in Britain. Most
of the programmes were European Oriented.
In 1951, assisted by the
British colonialists Nigeria
established the Nigerian Broadcasting Service. At this time there was clamor by
regional governments, to own and operate their own station. This was the advent
of rationalization and self-government. Having observed the penetrability of
radio medium regional governments were fascinated. According to Nwosu
(2004:18), with the leadership of the regions in the hands of black leaders
like Awolowo was vigorously escalated. Awalowo being an ambitious, dedicated
and goal oriented leader saw the radio as a means of radiating his ideas. This
led to the establishment of the Western Nigeria Broadcasting service in 1959.
Late Dr Okpara, who foresaw a better educated Eastern Nigerian, established the
Eastern Nigeria Broadcasting Service in 1963. Today, with the creation of 36
states radio stations have proliferated.
2.4
COMPONENTS OF THE MASS MEDIA
The mass media is traditionally
divided into the print and electronic media. The electronic media comprises the
radio, television, films; while the print media comprises the newspapers,
magazines. The two major types of the electronic media shall be discussed
briefly.
2.5
TELEVISION BROADCAST
According to Nwosu (2004:19),
television development was also not dramatic in Nigeria. It started in 1959 through
the efforts of the Western Regional Government. Late Chief Obafemi Awolowo
created the western Nigeria Telvision (WNTV). It came as rude shock to the then
federal government, which later started its own television.
Radio and television became a
hot cake to regional governments as formidable channels for penetrating the
populace and ensure national unity. At this time, it was not profitable for
private ownership. Even then very few governments were quick to acquire its
service. However, at the dying days of the General Babagida administration, the
broadcast ownership and operation was liberalized, through the areas of
transmission and telecast were limited.
The earliest experimental television
receivers used tiny screens based on cathode ray tubes about four inches in
diameter. Cameras were crude and required intense lighting. People who appeared
on experimental broadcast had to wear bizarre purple and gray make-up to
provide contrast for the picture. Development of television continued till the
end of World War II in 1945 when a number of television stations were
established and the public was ready to buy sets. The period of 1953 to 1960
was regarded as the golden age of television.
The role played by television
broadcasting in our contemporary society includes entertainments and
information. Television has the ability to deliver a story visually from the
scene of the action, making viewers feel as though they were at the scenes
themselves. It also presents an atmosphere of ease which viewers can receive
the news. Reading a story in the newspaper require much more concentration than
watching one on television. A routine newscast on a local station of the network
simply sketches even the main story with barely a sentence or two.
Network executives concede
quite readily that they provide little more than a headline service and that
for detailed information viewers must read newspaper (Sambe, 2005:110) the other
side of the coin is that many individual do not wish to know more about the
day’s event than television provides. Television as an audio-visual medium has
a far reaching impact on the society at large. It has made impact on the
activities of man culturally, emotionally, economically, and otherwise. Of all
the media in use today, television has been considered the most credible due to
its combination of audio-visual aesthetics. Finally, the impact of television
is so relevant to the media industry and to society that in the absence of
television, it will not angur well for both society and the media industry.
2.6
RADIO
Radio is undoubtedly the most
powerful instrument for nation building. Given our oral tradition, it is a
medium through which all part of the nation can be reached easily. Infact radio
has picked up as traditional media systems are being discarded. But as it often
is the case in Africa, dualism also subsists
in the media-the old co-exiting with the modern.
There is always a tendency to
forget that African has a rich media tradition. Indigenous communication
systems have always existed to dialogue, inform, educate and solve social
conflicts. Rural residents who constitute the majority of the continents
population use traditional means to disseminate information: a town crier walks
through the village at night striking his going to summon villagers to
community activities: a drum beat communicate death, imminent invasion or the
spread of an epidemic, and the lyrics in publicity performed songs aim to reduce
stress and help workers improve their work ethics. Certainly traditional
communication systems are a market place of ideas and skills.
The expansion and introduction
of radio, in recent times, is reducing the impact of these traditional systems.
The radio transmission involves the process by which messages are sent through
electoral signals into the air waves. In other words, sound could be sent and
received through these waves. The history of radio dates back to the 19th
century when Samuel Morse invented the Electronic telegraph. Gugielmo Marconi
built on the invention to produce electro-magnetic impulses, which could be
sent through the air without wire, carrying voice transmission over long
distance.
This series of invention
continued until 1920, a wireless manufacturing company in Bittsburg, USA
took patent to make regular broadcast, under the call sign KDKA. The KDKA thus
became the first broadcasting station in the world. Like television, radio
operates under strict Government control and scrutiny. Each station has a
license from the federal or state to broadcast on a specific Band with
designated power at certain authorized hours.
The radio station range from
extremely strong, clear channel, 50,000 watts transmitter whose signals can be
picked up hundred of miles away to low powered non-commercial stations with a
range of only a few miles. Many radio stations operate under joint ownership
with television stations. One major advantage the radio offers to advertisers
compared to television is its low cost, both for air time and for preparation of
the commercials. Also, radio is more flexible in time availability and the
speed with which it can accommodate new advertising copy. Radio however, lacks
the visual appeal that helps the television to have more patronage and
audience. Radio has not only succeeded in bringing government and its polices
to the citizen’s parlor, but serves as source of comfort. Radio is a good
friend in times of loneliness and partner in every circumstance.
2.7
PLANNING MASS MEDIA CAMPAIGN
This section describes relevant
communication and behaviour change theories that form the theoretical framework
for mass media campaign plans. These include risk communication behaviour
change, communication and information process theories. They provide a solid
foundation for mass media campaign plans. In this section, attempt will be made
to describe the major components of these theories and their application to the
mass media campaign plan.
2.8.1
RISK PERCEPTIONS AND RISK COMMUNICATION
Theories of risk perception and risk communication indicate
how audiences well perceive the FGM risks. Risk perception influences people’s
behaviour and response more than technical assessments (Frewer 2004:394)
Research conducted by Slovic (2000:24) has consistently demonstrated that:
Factors such as whether a risk
is perceived to be involuntary, potentially catastrophic or uncontrolled are
more important determinants of public response than technical risk information
alone.
Most members of the public are concerned about long-term effects
of risk, equity, fairness and lack of personal control (Renn, 2004:412). People
are more comfortable with threats that they can be before seen and planned for
rather than threats that could materialize themselves at anytime regardless of how
unlikely that might be (Renn, 2004: 410). In addition, people often seem much
more comfortable with familiar hazards. Moreover, they appear willing to
tolerate much higher risks from the former than the latter. Some consequences,
such as casualties, child mortality, death of children is more troublesome than
other consequences. These qualitative factors in risk assessment offer a
plausible explanation for the fact that risk resources deemed a low-risk by
technical assessment can be a source of great concern to the public.
Conversely, a high risk may be of less concern to the public. The following
factors affect risk assessment and change.
a. Familiarity
with the source of the risk.
b. Voluntary
acceptance of the risk.
c. Personal
control of, and ability to influence the risk
d. Natural
man-made causes of the risk.
e. Reliability of risk information sources
f. Clarity
of information on risk
g. Level
of community participation in the risk management process.
Therefore, messages about female genital mutilation and the
consequences of the practice on the female child will need to address any
misconceptions about risks and consequences.
2.8.2
BEHAVIOUR CHANGE THEORIES
Given that the mass media campaign plan will address
behavioural change. The campaign materials and messages should be based on the
behaviour change theory. The four-behaviour change theories are:
a. The
trans-theoretical model of Behaviour Change (also called the stage of change
model)
b. The
Health Belief Model.
c. The
theory of Reasoned Action
d. Social Learning Theory
2.8.3
Trans-theoretical model of Behaviour change (Stages of Changes).
According to the Trans-theoretical model of Behaviour
change, people tend to exhibit varying degrees of readiness or actual
involvement in the behaviour change process. The model places individual in
five stages that indicate their readiness to attempt, make or sustain behaviour
change. The five stages are:
a. Pre-contemplation
b. Contemplation
c. Preparation
d. Action
e. Maintenance
According to Prochaska and Diclemente (1983:393).
Stages are specific
to behaviour, and change is often cyclical, meaning that behaviour may slip
from one stage back to a previous stage
The varying levels of motivation and involvement of
individuals in the different stages may require different intervention,
materials or messages.
STAGES
OF CHANGE MODELL
The Trans-theoretical model of behaviour change offers a
detailed description of the stages mentioned above.
Pre-contemplation:
The individual
is not intending or even thinking about change in the foreseeable future
(usually measured as the next 6 months)
Contemplation:
The individual
is not prepared to take action at present, but is intending to within the next
6 months)
Preparation:
The individual
is actively considering his or her behaviour in the immediate future (e.g.
within the next 6 months).
Action:
The individual
has actually made an overt behaviour change in the recent past, but the change
are not well established (has been maintained for 6 months or less).
Maintenance:
The individual
has changed his or her behaviour, maintained the change for more than six
months and is working to sustain the change.
HEALTH
BELIEF MODEL
Beck and Maiman (1975:17) propose that people are likely to
engage in preventive behaviour if they believe that:
i. They
are susceptible to the potential problem (perceived susceptibility).
ii. The
problem has serious consequences (perceived severity).
iii. There
are few barriers to taking the preventive action (perceived barrier)
iv. The
preventive action will be effective in minimizing the risk (perceived benefits).
v. They
are capable of performing and maintaining the behaviour as is needed to obtain
the desire effect (perceived self-efficacy).
Additionally, individuals are more likely to engage in
preventive behaviour if they receive cues to action, which are environmental
cues that stimulate individuals to take action. The health belief model also
takes into account modifying factor that include demographic and
socio-psychological variables. Applying the health belief model to the campaign
against FGM, parents should be motivated to stand their ground if they believe
that:
i. They
or those who practice FGM are likely to have significant negative consequences.
ii. Avoiding
the practice would not be difficult or problematic. Finally, the target public
would also need cues to action, such as the mass media campaign, advice from
others and illness of a family member or friend.
2.8.4
THEORY OF REASONED ACTION
With regards to this theory of Reasoned Action (Ajzen and Fishbein,
1980:36) state that
Individuals decide to engage in
behaviour based on the outcome that they expect to occur because of that
behaviour.
The theory states that behaviour is predicted by the
individual’s attitude and subjective norm. attitude is a person positive or
negative feeling toward the behaviour, i.e. is the behaviour desirable or not?
Two variable feed into this attitude:
i. Behavioural
Beliefs, which are the perceived consequences of the behaviour
ii. Outcome
Evaluation, which is the personal evaluation of the consequence as positive or
negative.
Subjective norm is a person perceived social pressure to
think or behave in a certain way, that is, what others think the individuals should
do. Subjective norms affect an individual even when no one witnesses the
behaviour. Two variables make up subjective Norm:
i. Normative
belief: This is a person perception of what significant often think, believe or
do.
ii. The
motivation to comply with these referents.
The theory of Reasoned Action can be suitably applied to
media campaign against FGM. For the target public to avoid female genital
mutilation (FGM) they must believe that avoidance is desirable and will result
in positive outcomes with few or no consequences. In addition, they must
believe that significant others want them to avoid the practice and be motivated
to comply with the desire of others.
2.8.4
SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY
According to Bandura (1977), behaviour is explained as a
three way, dynamic, reciprocal process in which personal fact or environmental
influences, and behaviour continually interact. A basic premise of social
learning theory is that people learn not only through their own experiences,
but also by observing the actions of others and the result of those actions.
Again the social learning theory is applicable in mass
media campaign against female genital mutilation (FGM). Media messages
fashioned on this theory will highlight the negative consequences people have
suffered as a result of engaging in the harmful practice.
2.8.5 COMMUNICATION &
INFORMATION PROCESSING THEORIES
Extended Parallel Processing Model
The extended parallel processing model suggests that when
people perceive a serious and relevant threat they become frightened (Whitte,
1998:440). Once frightened, people are motivated to take action to reduce their
fear. In extended parallel processing model, individuals take two general paths
in response to the fear appeal. People can become motivated to control the
danger of the threat or to control their fear about the threat.
To control the danger, individuals consciously think about
the danger and how to get rid of it.
They review recommended
behaviour as a means to control the danger. In contrast, when people are
motivated to control their fear, they try to eliminate or reduce their fear
through denial, defensive, avoidance, or psychological reactance. Finally, if
people do not perceive a significant or relevant threat they will not be
motivated to take action.
People engage in danger control when they believe they can
easily and effectively avert the threat through recommended behaviour. In
contrast, people engage in fear control processes when they do not think they
are able to adopt a recommended response to avert a serious and relevant
threat. Several reasons account for this problem. It is either too hard or too
costly, it takes too much time, or the recommended behaviour will not
effectively avert the threat. Therefore, if any of the mass media campaign messages
contain fear appeal, it is critical that the messages include specific and easy
behaviour that individuals can practice to achieve the desired objectives.
Elaboration likelihood model
In elaboration likelihood model (Petty and Cacioppo, 1986:
125) portray messages receivers as active participants in the persuasion
process. The elaboration likelihood model describes two routes to persuasion:
Central and Peripheral.
i. The
central Route: The Central route to persuasion consists of thoughtful
consideration of the persuasive arguments in the message, and occurs only when
a receiver possesses both the motivation and ability to think about the message
and topic. The central route results in an attitude that is enduring and
resistant to change and predictive of behaviour.
ii. The
peripheral Route: The peripheral route occurs when the receiver lacks ability
and motivation to engage in much thought on the issue. Using the peripheral
route, the listener decides whether to agree with the message based on cues
other than the strength of the argument in the message. Such cues include:
i. Whether
the source is credible or attractive
ii. The
number (but not the quality) of arguments in the message
iii. The length of the message.
The peripheral route results in an attitude that is
temporary, susceptible, and unpredictive of behaviour. To ensure that the
target audience follows the central route to persuasion, the mass media
campaign messages must motivate target audience to think about the message. In
addition, the message should present numerous reasons to do away with the
harmful practice of FGM.
To conclude our discourse on various theories applicable to
mass media, campaign risk communication, Behaviour change and communication and
processing theories e.t.c, provide insight into the types of messages that mass
media campaign should develop and how target audience will respond to those
messages. The mass media campaign planning in this regard should:
i. Target
avoidance behaviour rather than just creating awareness or knowledge.
ii. Leverage
resource through partnerships and earned media coverage.
iii. Address
environmental factors related to the problem at stake.
iv. Include
plans for process and outcome evaluation
v. Segment
audiences and develop distinct campaign plans and elements for those segments.
2.9 COMMUNICATION CAMPAIGNS
Individuals and communities can link most premature death
in developed countries to action or the lack of action. (Mcginms and Fooge
1993:193) as a result, public health practitioners have developed interventions
to promote healthy attitudes, actions and suppress those, which place life and
health in jeopardy.
Communication maybe a dominant player or may have a
supporting role in any such intervention. Other roles may include communication
strategies such as public relations, where the objective is to target health
issues on the public agenda, entertainment, education where desired behaviour
are modeled in an entertainment
programme and media advocacy which entails using the media as an advocacy tool
to achieve policy level change. All of these strategies may include a range of
communication activities that occur at the individual, small group or mass
media levels.
This section addresses only those communication activities that
use media outlets more specifically, the implementation and effects of mass
media health communication campaign.
Rogers
and Storey (1987:94) maintain that health communication campaign have four
defining characteristics. The campaign therefore must strive to generate
specific outcome or effect in a relatively large number of individuals usually within
a specific period of time through an organized set of communication activities.
Health communication campaign that rely on mass media outlets frequently
consist of a series of television and radio public service announcements (PASA)
or paid commercial with collateral print materials such as posters, brochure
booklets e.t.c.
Most health communications would agree that there is a
common set of variables considered in the development of a mass media health communication
campaign and a common set of outcomes that one can reasonably except as a
result of a communication experience. Communication development or independent
variables can be categorized into four areas:
i. Psycho
social attributes of receiver.
ii. The
source or spokesperson.
iii. Setting,
channels, activities and materials, used to disseminate the message.
iv. The
message itself, including content, tone type of appeal, audio characteristics
and visual attributes.
Taken together any combination of these four independent variables
constitutes what it referred to as communication strategy. According to Flora
and Maibach (1990:100) the outcomers or dependent variables of a mass health
communication effort maybe categorized into six broad area:
i. Yielding
ii. Attention
iii. Comprehension
iv. Attitude
change
v. Behaviour.
By and large the researcher must acknowledge at the outset
that these outcomes are not meant to imply that the progressions of these
outcomes are linear in nature. The research however, believes that these terms
will provide a common language pertinent to this discussion.
2.10
THE ISSUES ON FEMALE GENITAL
MULTILATION
Right from the time of old,
circumcision has been performed on both female and male children in Africa and also other continents of the world. But the
circumcision of male children has some biblical backing. However, the male
circumcision is the cutting off of the foreskin from the tip of penis without
damaging the organ itself. The degree of cutting in female circumcision is anatomically
much more extensive. While the male circumcision affirms manhood with its
superior social status and association to virility. The female circumcision is
explicitly intended to show a woman her confined role in social strata and to
restrain her sexual desires.
The female circumcision (FC)
which is now known as female Genital Mutilation (FGM) is widely regarded as the
most serious form of violence against woman. It is the collective name given to
several forms of traditional practices that involve the cutting of sensitive
female genitals.
The age at which FGM is
performed differs depending on the customs and circumstances of the families involved.
Some girls are circumcised few days older, when there is no possibility of the
individual consent. Some are teenager. Girls may be circumcised in groups with
older girls. Some girls or women undergo FGM a few months before marriage. A
traditional practitioner, often an older woman, who comes from a family in
which generations of women have been traditional practitioners, usually
performs FGM.
There are several myths and
beliefs. Surrounding this practice in Africa
as to why girls and women undergo FGM. Adelaja (2004) traces the origin of this
socio-trado cultural practice to the misconception associated with the female
genitalia.
i. The
clitoris is the cap of prostitution which the vagina wears from heaven.
ii. If
they do not clip the clitoris young, it will ask for great sacrifices from the
penis when it grows up.
iii. An uncircumcised woman is not to be respected.
iv. The
uncircumcised woman will give birth to still born babies, that is contact between
the clitorises and the baby’s head will cause the death of the baby.
v. The
clitoris causes itching and is always dirty and emits unpleasant odour.
vi. The
Female genitalia is ugly and the often ding organ is the clitoris.
vii. Female Genital Mutilation (FGM) has become a entrenched, in
cultures of many African countries and other continent of the world, World
Health Organization (WHO) has estimated that over 130 million girls and women
have undergone some type of female genital mutilation (FGM), and this figure is
added with 2 million each year (Abusharaf, 2006:3).
The following descriptions of FGM are used by WHO is define
the most common types of FGM. The following are the different types:
i. Cutting
of the prepuce, with or without excision of parts of the entire clitoris.
ii. Cutting
of the clitoris, and prepuce together with partial or total excision of the
Labia minoria (Clitoridectomy)
iii. Excision
of part or all of the Labia minoria and Labia Majora, and stitching or
narrowing of the vagina orifice, leaving an opening to allow for the flow of
urine and menstrual blood (infibulations)
iv. Unclassified
picking, piercing, stretching clitoris or Labia cauterizing the clitoris by
burning, scraping or cutting the vagina, inserting substances into the vagina with
the purpose of causing bleeding and there by tightening and narrowing the
vagina (Abusharaf, 2006: 6).
There are several physical and psychological effects of
female genital mutilation. The effects could be in extreme cases lead to death.
Megafu (1983:25) states that
When the mutilation is carried
out pain, shock, hemorrhage, and damage to the organs surrounding the clitoris
and labia can occur. Afterwards, urine maybe retained and serious infection
develops. Use of the same instrument or several girls without sterilization can
cause the spread of HIV
The World Health Organization (WHO) has recognized that the
genital mutilation of girls and women represents a serious form of FGM such as
infibulations, victims are particularly likely to suffer from health
complications requiring medical attention throughout their lives. Such
situation puts a lot of physical and psychological complication on the victim.
The known immediate complications resulting from female genital mutilation
includes infection, shock, Hemorrhage, injury to adjacent vital tissues and the
following are long term complications which include infertility,
Keloid-formation, permanently painful genital and area or fistulae (VVF or RVF)
resulting from injuries to dorsal nerve of the clitoris, de-infibulations (re-infibulations,
HIV transmission, obstructed and prolonged labour (WHO 1997:10).
There is today greater understanding of the epidemiological
consequences of female genital mutilation due largely to the activities of some
non-governmental organizations working in countries where the practice is
widespread. Infibulations is practiced in Djibouti,
Egypt, some parts of Ethiopia, Mali,
Somalia and Northern part of
Sudan.
Excision and circumcision occur in parts of Benin,
Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Nigeria,
Northern part of Ghana, Senegal, e.t.c.
However, the incidence of these problems and of deaths as a
result of mutilation cannot be reliably estimated. Supporters of this practice
claim that major complications and problems are rare, while opponents of the
practice claim that they are frequent. Despite the many campaigns by Government
and private organizations round the world, this ugly practice still lingers on
in most of the developing countries of the world.
CHAPTER
THREE
METHODOLOGY
3.1
POPULATION OF THE STUDY
The population of the study
shall be made up of students in secondary and tertiary institution, market men
and women who have lock up shops in the market and finally Etsako local
government staff.
3.2
SAMPLE OF THE STUDY
Since it will be nearly
important to assist or interview all the men and women in Etsako East, a sample
of the population will be selected for the study. The sample group will be made
up of the following.
40 men and women who have lock
up shops,
40 students in secondary and
tertiary institutions
40 Etsako East Local government
staff.
3.3 RESEARCH DESIGN
Every research conducted scientifically, has special
framework for controlling data gathering or collection. This framework is the
research design. The purpose however, is to obtain accurate, objective and
valid information.
In this study, the survey method of conducting research
will be used. In this case, a well structured questionnaire will be used. In
this case, a well structured questionnaire will personally be administered to
the target sample population in Etsako East Local Government Area.
3.4 SAMPLING TECHNIQUES
With regard to this nature of the study a non-profit ability
sampling method will be adopted. However, to be scientific, men and women who
have lock up shops for every distance of five electric poles from Igiode junction
to central garage will be selected for questionnaire interview. 10 students
from five selected streets will be selected and finally 40 workers of the local
government council entering or leaving the local government promises will be
administered questionnaire.
3.5
DESCRIPTION FOR RESEARCH
INSTRUMENT
The research instrument design
for this study is the questionnaire. The questions are self explanatory and
spaces are provided for the respondents to indicate their response. Some of the
questions for the study are structured in such a way as to give the respondents
the free will to provide answers as he/she pleases.
However, other questions
restrict the respondents to choose from a list of possible answers.
3.6
METHOD OF DATA ANALYSIS
In order to give the data
collected through the questionnaire meaning, and to achieve the objectives
sought in the study, simple percentage will be used to analyze responses
gathered from the field.
CHAPTER
FOUR
DATA
PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS
4.1
DATA PRESENTATION
In this chapter, the data
gathered through the survey information or instrument will be presented and
analyzed. The sample size of the study population is 95 respondents. In other
words only 95 questionnaire were returned from the 120 questionnaires
administered.
These returned questionnaires
represent 79% of the study population because 25 questionnaires could not be
returned. The table below shows raw figures and percentages of the number of
questionnaires distributed and the number returned.
Categories
|
Number distributed
|
Number returned
|
Percentage
|
Civil servants
|
40
|
35
|
29.2%
|
Shop owners
|
40
|
37
|
31%
|
Students
|
40
|
23
|
19.2%
|
Total
|
120
|
95
|
79%
|
From the table above, the
number of questionnaires distributed was 120, those returned represent 79.2% of
administered questionnaires, while 25 representing 20.8% of the questionnaire
were not returned.
4.2
PRESENTATION AND ANALYSIS OF DEMOGRAPHIC
DATA
TABLE 1 AGE
Age
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
20-30
|
19
|
20%
|
30-40
|
25
|
26.32%
|
40-50
|
27
|
28.42%
|
50-above
|
24
|
25.26%
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From table 1 above, 19
respondents were between 20-30 years old. This represents 20% 30-40 years old
were 25 respondents or 26-32%.40-50 years were 27 respondents or 28.42% 50 and above
were 24 respondents or 25.26%.
TABLE
2: GENDER
Gender
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Male
|
44
|
46.32
|
Female
|
51
|
53.68
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the analysis in table 2
above, 44 respondents or 46.32% were male. While 51 respondents or 53.68% were
female
TABLE 3 EDUCATIONAL
QUALIFICATION
Education
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Primary
|
8
|
8.42
|
Secondary
|
20
|
21.05
|
Polytechnic
|
35
|
36.84
|
University
|
26
|
27.27
|
Others
|
6
|
6.32
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the table above, 8 respondents or 8.42% were primary
school certificate holders. 20 respondents representing 21.05% have secondary
education. The remaining balance of 67 respondent represent 70.53% of this
study population have attained tertiary education.
TABLE 4: OCCUPATION
Occupation
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Students
|
23
|
24.21%
|
Business
|
37
|
38.95%
|
Civil
servants
|
35
|
36.84%
|
Other
|
-
|
-
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the above table, 23 respondents or 24.21% were
students. 37 respondents 38.95% were business men and women. While civil servants
were 35 respondents representing 36.84%
4.3
PRESENTATION ANALYSIS OF
PSYCHOGRAPHIC DATA
Table 5: Do you know anything
about female circumcision or female genital mutilation?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
49
|
51.57
|
No
|
21
|
22.11
|
Not sure
|
25
|
26.32
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the above table 49 respondents or 51.57% agrees that
they know something about female genital mutilation? 21 respondents or 26.32%
claim that they don’t know about it. While 25 respondents or 26. 32% are not
sure about it.
Table 6: What is your Opinion
about female genital mutilation?
Opinion
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
It is a good cultural
practice
|
32
|
33.68
|
It is a bad cultural practice
|
12
|
12.63
|
It affect the health of
female child
|
29
|
30.53
|
The practice should be made a
punishable offence to deter others
|
22
|
23.16
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the table, 32 respondents or 36.8 are of the opinion
that FGM is a good cultural practice. 12 respondents or 12.63% are of the
opinion that, it is a bad cultural practice. 29 respondents or 30.53% agreed
that it affects the health of female child, while 22 respondents or 23.16% are
of the opinion that the practice should be made punishable to deter others.
Table 7: Have you ever heard
that FGM practices are dangerous to health?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
41
|
43.16
|
No
|
20
|
21.5
|
Not sure
|
34
|
35.79
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the above, 41 respondents or 43.16% have heard about
the danger of FGM. 20 respondents, or 21.05% have not heard about it. While 34
respondents or 35.79% are not sure and did not respond to the question.
Table 8: Is there an age limit
for F.G.M practices in your area
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
52
|
54.74
|
No
|
22
|
23.16
|
Not sure
|
21
|
22.10
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the above table, 52 respondents or 54.74% agree that
there is an agree age limit for the practice in their area. 22 respondents or
23.16% has no age limit in their area. 21 or 22.10% are not sure.
Table 9: Do you know that there
is a campaign against the practice.
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
51
|
53.7
|
No
|
29
|
30.52
|
Not sure
|
15
|
15.78
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
The above table shows that 51 representing 53.7%
respondents agree that they are aware of the campaign of the FGM practice. 29
or 30.52% agreed that they don’t know about the campaign, and 15 representing
15.78% respondents are not sure.
Table 10: Which of the
following media have you heard, seen or read about the campaign against the
practices (FGM)
Medium
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Newspaper
|
16
|
16.84
|
Radio
|
32
|
32.63
|
Television
|
41
|
43.16
|
Internet
|
2
|
2.11
|
Magazine
|
5
|
5.26
|
Leaflet
|
-
|
-
|
Billboards
|
-
|
-
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the above table, it shows that 16 respondents have
read about it. 31 respondents or 32.63% have heard about it, 41 respondents or
43.16% have seen the campaign from the Internet. While, 5 respondents 5.26%
read from magazine. Leaflet and billboards are not significant.
Table 11: From which of these
media below do you understand the problems of FGM most?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Newspaper
|
24
|
25.26
|
Radio
|
29
|
30.53
|
Television
|
42
|
44.21
|
Internet
|
-
|
-
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
In the table, 24 respondents or 25.26% out of the total
number submitted that newspaper is most under standable medium to them. 29
respondents or 30.35% says that radio is more understandable to them. 42 respondents
or 44.22% submitted that television is the most understandable.
Table 12: Do you agree with the
message you receive from these media?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
30
|
31.58%
|
No
|
32
|
33.68%
|
Not sure
|
33
|
34.74%
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
The above table shows that 30 representing 31.58%
respondents agree with the message 32 or 33.68% respondents disagree with the
message they receive. While 33 representing 34.74% respondents are not sure, if
they agree with the message.
Table 13: Which of these media
do you rely on mostly for your information?
Medium
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Newspaper
|
17
|
17.89
|
Radio
|
21
|
22.11
|
Television
|
57
|
60
|
Internet
|
-
|
-
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
The table above shows that people in Etsako East rely on
Television for information. 17 respondents or 17.88% rely on newspaper to get
information. 21 respondents or 22.11% rely on Radio. 57 respondents or 60% rely
on television to get information on F.G.M.
Table 14: In your own opinion
do you think FGM practice has reduced in this town (Etsako)
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
21
|
22.11%
|
No
|
57
|
60%
|
Not sure
|
17
|
17.89
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
It can be argued from behaviour of the respondents that
there is no reduction in the town. Whereby 21 respondents or 22.11% agree that
there is no reduction. 57 respondents or 60% disagree to the position. 17
respondents or 17.89% were not sure of the reduction.
Table 15: Do you think that
circumcision has a dangerous effect on the victims?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
22
|
23.16
|
No
|
53
|
55.79
|
Not sure
|
20
|
21.05
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the above table, 22 respondents or 23.16% agree that
the practice is dangerous. 53 respondents or 55.79% disagree to the position.
20 or 31.05% do not know if it has a dangerous effect.
Table 16: When was the last
time you saw somebody that was circumcised.
Option
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
1-6mnth ago
|
47
|
49.47
|
6-1yr ago
|
14
|
14.74
|
1-3yr ago
|
21
|
22.11
|
Over 3yrs ago
|
13
|
13.68%
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the table 47 respondents or 49.47% claimed that the
last time they saw a circumcised girl was 1-6 months ago. 14 or 14.74%
respondents claimed it was 6-1yr ago 21 or 22.11% respondents were 1-3yr ago,
while 13 or 13.68% respondents was over 3yrs ago.
Table 17: From the messages you
have been hearing, reading or watching from the various media, will you
subscribe to the circumcision of your female child?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
39
|
41.05%
|
No
|
38
|
40.00
|
Not sure
|
18
|
18.95
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
The table above shows that 39 or 41.05 respondents agree
that they will subscribe to the circumcision of their female child. 38 or
40.00% respondents will not 18 or 18.95% did not respond.
Table 18: Do these messages
really convey the harmful and dangerous effects of female circumcision?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
64
|
67.37
|
No
|
20
|
21.05
|
Not sure
|
11
|
11.58
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the above, there is that overwhelming consensus that
the messages really convey the harmful and damaging effect of F.G.M. This is
represented by 64 or 67.37% respondents that the message really bring out the
damaging aspects of F.G.M 20 or 21.05% respondents disagree on this position.
From the table two, 11 or 11.58% respondents could be interested to be
different over the issue under study. Therefore one can positively generalize
that the public are being informed of the danger.
Table 19: Do you desire to help
in carrying on with the campaign against F.G.M in a positive manner?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
32
|
33.68
|
No
|
48
|
50.53
|
Not sure
|
15
|
15.79
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
In the above table, 32 respondents or 33.68% agreed to
assist in the campaign positively. 48 respondents or 50.33% did not agree. 15
respondents or 15.79% refuse to comment as to assist in the campaign. This
could indicate that some persons in the society still will not want to maintain
the status quo
Question FGM.
Table 20: In your opinion,
should F.G.M be abolished and offenders punished by the law?
Response
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
21
|
22.11
|
No
|
32
|
33.68
|
Not sure
|
42
|
44.21
|
Total
|
95
|
100%
|
From the table above, 21 or 22.11% respondents are of the
opinion that F.G.M should be abolished and offenders to be punished, 32 or 33.68%
did not agree to this position. While 42 or 44.21% respondents are not sure,
also did not respond to the question.
4.4
DISCUSSION OF FINDINGS
The data gathered from the
questionnaires of this study in Etsako of Edo State is quite revealing.
Response from the respondents about the campaign against F.G.M is quite
overwhelming. 51 respondents representing 51.7% agreed to have been aware of
campaigns against the practice 29 and 15.78% respondent representing 30.52% and
15.78% respectively are not sure of their knowledge in this regard. However, it
is tenable to conclude that majority of the public are aware about the campaign
against the practice of female genital mutilation.
Of these 95 respondents, 49
respondents representing 51.77% have full knowledge of the practice and its
effect on the female child. 21 respondents or 22.11% have no knowledge of the
practice at all 26.32% respondents are not sure and didn’t respond.
In respect of the question on
sources of creating FGM awareness. A research finding shows that three media
(Television 43.16%, Radio 32,63%, newspaper 16.83%) are effective in bringing
about some level of desired awareness.
Of all the mass media available
in the area 44.21% respondents agree that Television is the most effective
medium of creating awareness. From the above analysis one can infer that
television is the most effective medium of disseminating campaign against FGM
in Etsako East L.G.A.
Research findings reveal that
the prevalent rates of the practice have not reduced. 60% respondent agree with
this view point.
4.5
SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
The research summarizes that
among the various mass media of communication used in the campaign against the
practice of female Genital Mutilation (FGM), television is the most effective.
This is as a result of the aesthetic characteristics of the electronic medium.
Its audio-visual compliments present the message(s) in both sound and picture
form. Viewers are, therefore in a better situation to understand the medium’s
presentations.
Some of the media are not effective
in this area despite the resources committed to them and the perceived mileage
of the mass media.
However, due to prevailing
trado-cultural practices 33.68% respondents still think and believe that the
practice is good. This accounts for the 23.16% respondents who opposed to any
formal punishment against those who indulge in the practice. Another 22.16% are
not sure that any form of punishment is desirable.
Majority are of the opinion
that the practice should not be abolished. One would expect that because of
education and Christianity, a lot of people in Agenebode should condemn the FGM
practice but the reverse seem to be the case.
CHAPTER
FIVE
5.1
SUMMARY OBSERVATION
Mass media campaign remains an
important strategy for health promotion, social orientation disease prevention
and control. This fact cannot be overemphasized. The objective of this study is
to investigate the effectiveness of mass media campaign against female genital
mutilation. The aim is targeted at generating awareness, knowledge and propels
the level of change required against the practice. Furthermore, the study also
attempted to ascertain the level of effectiveness of mass media campaign in
Etasko East Local Government Area. Research findings of the study reveal the
following:
i. There
is a reasonable knowledge of the practice (FGM) but only few people in
Agenebode are aware of the harmful effect on the female child.
ii. Television,
Radio and Newspapers are the most effective mass media in the campaign against
F.G.M
iii. The practice rate of the phenomenon has not significantly reduced
in the area understudy. Many still have the belief that the practice is
culturally good.
iv. The
traditional beliefs and cultural practice of the people in Etsako East are
still posing a big obstacle to the full realization of eliminating the harmful
practice.
v. The
increasing level of education and the rapid spread of Christianity among the
people in Agenebode town have however contributed to a gradual reduction in the
rate of the practice.
5.2 RECOMMENDATION
Based on research findings of the study, the following
recommendations are proffered.
i. The
most effective tool in creating community awareness of the harmful aspect of
FGM still remains sensitization through propaganda, media and outdoor drama
performed as well as seminars and Workshops. Expanding these activities to the
grass roots within the various villages will increase the level of awareness of
the harmful aspects of the practice and lead to its further decline.
ii. The
electronic media should carry the message more frequency before each broadcast
schedule.
iii. The
message content of the campaign against form should be written and produced in
local languages, Pidgin English in addition to the English Language version
iv. Using
the traditional cultural means of information dissemination as opposed to the
common judgemental and incriminating “stop the practice” approach of the media
campaign, will yield better results.
v. Therefore,
direct approaches like community drama and workshops will help carry the
message of campaigns against the practice more geographically.
vi. To
avoid disharmony among community members, any approach used to campaign against
the practice of FGM should be comprehensive and integrated involving all
members of the community.
vii. Parents should be encouraged to educate the girl child
legislations should make it compulsory.
viii. Sex
education should be incorporated into the school curriculum at the primary and
secondary levels. In this way many harmful and unhealthy practices will be
gradually eliminated.
5.3 CONCLUSION
The essence of the study is to establish direct link
between mass media campaign intervention and subsequent public awareness,
knowledge, attitude and behaviour change against FGM in Etsako East, Local Government
Area.
The study has established that the mass media of
television, Radio and Newspaper have a great impact in creating awareness,
knowledge and consequently behaviour change against the practice of FGM in
Agenebode in Etsako East Local Government Area.
Considering the people’s strong traditional belief and the
negative consequences of the practice of female genital mutilation, it will be
quite encouraging to enforce the campaign against the practice with more
intensity. The research believes that if its recommendation are implemented,
the negative practice will eventually die out with time.
WORK
CITED
Abusharaf,
F.M Introduction: The custom in Question. Pennsylvania:
university of Pennsylvania press, 2006.
Adejala,
O.A, Final report on the position of female circumcision in Nigeria. Lagos. Federal Ministry
of health, 1981.
Ajzen,
I and Fishbein, M, understanding Attitude and predicting social Behaviour. Englewood cliffs, N.J.
Prentice Hall, 1986.
Andreason,
A, Marketing social change: Changing Behaviour to promote Health, Social
Development, and the Environment. San
Francisco: Jossey-Bass, 1995.
Bandura,
A, Social Learning theory: Englewood
cliffs, NJ prentice-Hall, 1977.
Becker,
M.H, and Maiman, L.A, “Social Behavioural Determinants of compliance with
Health and Medical Recommendations” in medical care. Vol. 13, No 1 (February,
1975), 3-11.
Flora,
J.A, and Maibach, E.W “Cognitive Response to AIDS information: The effect of
issue involvement and message Appeal” in communication Research, vol. 4, 1 (April
1990), 31-43.
Frewer,
L, “The public and Effective Risk Communication”. Toxicology letters, vol. 20,
1-5 (September 2000), 4-10
Ikem,
N, Mass media and Nigerian society. Enugu:
cecta Nig. Ltd, 2004.
Mcginnis,
J.M, and Foege, W.H. “Actual causes of Death in the United States” Journal of the
American Medical association, vol. 8, 24, (December, 1993).
Ogbiten
B.O Decoder: A Glossary of Mass Communication and Marketing Terms. Lagos. Amfitop Books,
2008.
Petty,
R.E and Cacioppo, J.T, “Elaboration likelihood model of persuasion” in
Berkowitz, L. (ed.) Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, vol. 2, Orlando, FI: Academic
press, 1986. 5-16.
Prochaska,
P.O and Diclemente, C.C, “Stages and processes of self change of smoking:
Toward an Integrative Model of Change”. Journal of consulting and clinical
psychology, vol. 2, No 3 (April 1983), 26-42
Rean,
O, “Perception of Risks”. Toxicology Letters, vol. 20, 1.5 (September 2000),
1-3.
Sambe,
J.A. Introduction to mass communication Practice in Nigeria. Ibadan. Spectrum Books Ltd, 2005.
Steinberg,
C.S, 1972. The communicative Art: An introduction to mass Media. New York: Hastings
House Publishers, 1972.
World
Health Organization. “Health Reports”, Bi-Annual Bulletin, vol. 12. Geneva. 1997, 1-7.
World
Health Organization, “Female Genital mutilation. What works and what doesn’t a
Review”. Bi-Annual Bulletin, vol. 12, Geneva:
1997, 12-23.
World
Health Organization 2002, “Prevention of Psychoactive substance use: A selected
Review of prevention” Bi-annual Bulletin, vol. 12, Geneva 1917, 48-57
Ambroses Alli
University,
Department of Theatre and Media
Arts Ekpoma.
15th November, 2011.
Dear Respondents,
My name is Ifietekhai Francisca
Adene a final year student of the above named department.I am conducting a
research study entitled. AN ASSESSMENT OF MASS MEDIA CAMPAIGN AGAINST FEMALE
GENITAL MUTILATION in Agenebode Etsako East Local Government Area of Edo
State.This questionnaire is designed to elicit your opinions on this topic.your
opinions will be very useful to this study and your information will be treated
with utmost confidence.this study is purely an academic exercise.thanks for
your anticipated kind response
SECTION
A
INSTRUCTION:
PLEASE TICK AGAINST YOUR CHOICE OF OPTION IN THE BOX PROVIDED.
DEMOGRAPHIC
INFORMATION
1. How
old are you? (a) 20-30 (b) 40-50 (c) 30-40 (d) 50 above.
2. What
is your gender? (a) Male (b) Female
3. What
is your highest level of education (a) Primary (b) Secondary
(c) Polytechnic (d)
University
4. What
do you do for a living? (a) Student (b) Business (c) Civil Servant (d) Others
SECTION B
5. Do
you know anything about female circumcision or female Gender Mutilation (FGM)?
Yes ( ) No ( )
6. What is your opinion about female Genital mutilation? (a) It is
a good cultural practice (b) it is a bad cultural day (c) it affects the health
of the female child (d) the practice should be made a punishable offence to
deter others.
7. Have you ever heard that FGM practices are dangerous to health?
(a) Yes (b) No (c) Not sure.
8. Is
there any limit for F.G.M practice in your area? (a) Yes (b) No (c) Not idea.
9. Do
you know that there is a campaign against this practice? (a) Yes (b) No (c) Not
idea.
10. In which of the following media have you heard or seen the
campaign against the practice? (a) Newspaper, (b) Radio, (c) Television (d)
Internet (e) Magazine (d) leaflets (e) Billboards.
11. From
which of these media below do you understand the problems of FGM most? (a)
Newspaper (b) Radio (c) Television (d) Internet (e) Magazines (d) Leaflets (c)
Bill boards.
12. Do
you agree with the message you receive from these media? (a) Yes (b) No (c) Not
sure.
13. Which
of these media do you rely on mostly for your information? (a) Newspaper (b)
Radio (c) Television (d) Internet (e) Magazine (f) Leaflets (g) Bill boards.
14. From
your opinion do you think FGM practice has reduced in this town? (a) Yes (b) No
(c) Not sure.
15. Do you thin that circumcision has a dangerous effect on the
victim? (a) Yes (b) No (c) Not sure.
16. When was the last time you saw somebody that was circumcised (a)
1-6mnth ago (b) 6mnth-1yr ago (c) 1yr-3yr ago (d) Over 3yr ago.
17. From
the messages you have been hearing, reading and watching from the various
media, will you subscribe to the circumcision of your female child? (a) Yes (b)
No (c) Not sure
18. Do these message really convey the harmful and damaging effects
on female circumcision? (a) Yes (b) No (c) Not sure.
19. Do
you desire to help in carrying on with the campaign against female circumcision
in a positive manner? (a) Yes (b) No (c) Not sure.
20. In your opinion, should FGB be abolished and offenders punished
by the law? (a) Yes (b) No (c) Not sure.
Are you Happy with Nurt9ja?
Make a Donation Today to Multiply the Free Materials Today:
Bank Details
Admin: Acct. Name. Umar Isunoya Ibrahim
Acct. No.: 6019090219 - Fidelity Bank
Acct. No.: 0161209600 - GT-Bank
Acct. No.: 0737214916 Access Bank
For Complaint, Confirmation etc.
Contact: nurt9ja/ Ibrahim on 08100770125
WE love commentaries, it keeps us alive, keep on showering us with the comments about our topics so we can know how to upgrade and satisfy you better. DON'T FORGET TO LIKE AND SHARE ON OUR SOCIAL MEDIA HANDLE
ReplyDelete